As the highly anticipated clash between West Ham and Arsenal approaches, David Moyes finds himself grappling with a selection headache, particularly concerning star defender Nayef Aguerd. The upcoming match at the London Stadium promises to be a significant encounter in the Premier League calendar, with both teams vying for crucial points.

Quality Depth vs. Squad Size

In the realm of squad depth, Arsenal holds the advantage over West Ham, boasting a greater array of quality options in most positions. Mikel Arteta, accustomed to managing selection dilemmas, navigates through choices with relative ease. In contrast, Moyes has consistently expressed a preference for a smaller squad, a sentiment reflected in West Ham’s lean roster post-January transfer window.

Defensive Competition: Aguerd vs. Mavropanos

While West Ham faces challenges in squad depth, one area of contention lies in central defense, where Nayef Aguerd and Konstantinos Mavropanos vie for starting positions. Mavropanos notably impressed in West Ham’s recent outings, particularly in the memorable victory against Arsenal last December. However, Moyes opted to field Aguerd in the recent defeat to Manchester United, a decision met with scrutiny given Aguerd’s inconsistent performances and costly errors.

Balancing Act: Left-Footed Defenders and Defensive Stability

Moyes justified his selection of Aguerd over Mavropanos by citing the need for a left-footed defender to maintain defensive balance. However, Aguerd’s penchant for errors raises questions about his suitability for the starting lineup. Despite possessing a formidable left foot, Aguerd’s lapses in concentration have occasionally marred his contributions on the pitch.

The Manager’s Conundrum

As the showdown with Arsenal looms, Moyes must carefully weigh his defensive options. While Aguerd brings certain attributes to the table, Mavropanos has proven himself as a reliable and consistent performer. The decision to drop Mavropanos in favor of Aguerd against Manchester United sparked debate among fans and pundits alike, highlighting the complexity of Moyes’ dilemma.